‘Tis that time in the early basketball season when strong teams pummel weak teams. But, even when playing an outmatched opponent most strong teams display respect for the weaker opponent; they don’t run up the score.
It’s got a name: sportsmanship. Apparently that’s a vague term for some. On November 5, LSU’s top ten women’s basketball team beat a hapless Texas Southern University team by 109 points!
In early 2015, I wrote a relevant blog. Here it is again with extensive revisions.
Most of us, seeing a lopsided score, like 162 to 2, instinctively react with questions about fairness and sportsmanship. We do so because we humans have a natural inclination toward treating others like we would like to be treated.
I did say “most of us”. There are hardcore Darwinists who misguidedly eschew helping others; fortunately they are in a minority but they are with us nevertheless and come in various disguises. Most of us learn early not to “kick someone when they’re down”, not to “pile on”, “hit below the belt” or to “add insult to injury”.
A decade ago, that blowout girl’s basketball game (162-2) got national attention of the unwanted kind. The winning coach, as a punishment for unsportsmanlike conduct, was suspended for two games.
I’ve used sports as points of departure for commenting on teamwork and collaboration, so this story joins previous blogs**, one about offering a hand-up to a downed opponent, another about aiding a fellow runner to cross the finish line, and a third about literally carrying an opposing team’s player to victory – all which might qualify as “man bites dog” stories.
That’s because, contrary to human instincts, popular sports opinion and practice is to never help your opponent. You don’t win by helping the other guy.
So it is not surprising that the piling-on coach’s suspension enraged some fans. Their view: fire the loser coach. Many see nothing wrong in running up the score. After all, it’s good for kids to experience defeat. The losing coach obviously did a lousy job in preparing his team; if you can’t run with the big dogs, don’t.
You get the idea.
“People shouldn’t feel sorry for my team,” the losing coach said, “They should feel sorry for the (winning) team, which isn’t learning the game the right way.”
Is there supposed to be a tacit understanding among players and coaches that when the score is one-sided, the stronger team needs to let up, clear the bench, rotate out the starters and let the practice players play? That’s not dispensing mercy, that’s class and opportunity for players with few minutes playing to gain live game experience. Not doing so is poor sportsmanship.
Or, is this teary-eyed wimpiness, a caving in to the “everyone’s a winner” self-esteem, participant trophy crowd?
I’m on the side of the former – always be the gracious winner or loser. If you’re in a mismatch – an athletic team with a history of winning and veteran players vs. an inexperienced team – then you need to resist the temptation to lord it over the other team.
In the lop-sided game the winning coach used a full court press – flustering novice players – for the entire first half. Then, relentlessly switched from the full court press to “trapping” – 2 or 3 players surrounding the player with the ball, forcing a time out or a held ball or literally ripping the ball away.
I’m the last person to say there’s no value in getting trounced by a better team – it’s why women teams in college use men practice players –to get better. A beatdown can ramp up one’s game, but not if you’re in shellshock!
What about the winning players and their development as leaders and followers? Did any of the winning players confront their coach: “This is embarrassing me. Can we quit hammering them and play this like a Varsity/Junion Varsity scrimmage?” Or did the players delude themselves, “Wow! We’re the best, ever!” In that case, they lost.
The winning coach issued a non-apology: “the game just got away from me”. For a coach who had several championship season before and after this debacle, he displayed a dismaying lack of control over himself (and his players). To his credit, “Following the incident, the coach publicly committed to managing lopsided games differently, avoiding high-pressure full-court presses against severely outmatched opponents.”
There’s a glimmer of leadership, a sliver of leading by example.
What does this have to do with workplace teams?
Plenty. Remember, sport is indeed “always more than a game.”***
Respect for other work teams matters; how you compete and “play the game” matters in the organization. Treating other work teams with respect and in a cooperative spirit advances organizational goals. Focusing on only one team’s goal to the exclusion of other teams does the opposite.
I recall how in a large department one unit was always helping other units in that department. However, helping anyone outside that department was a “no way”. I never understood why not.
A shared achievement is better for the organization than one team claiming the trophy (recognition and reward) at the expense of others. A team that talks trash about other work teams is acting unethically and, often has advantages other teams lack. If you are a champion team, don’t be a rumor monger. Instead, air your differences with that other team, in private, and once you’ve made your point – and heard their side – offer to help that team in real and supportive ways to get better. Learn to pull together in the same direction.
OK, but what to do when you are up against a terribly weak team, one that is pulling down the organization? I think this has to be met with the same openness, listening and consideration. The outcome may well be different – the team may need to dissolve – but at least the decision is made in an upfront, caring and cooperative way.
*Playing with Quality – the early version of this blog -appeared in January of 2015. I used the word quality as an attribute of a Gentlewoman or a Gentleman.
** A few other of my sports blogs:
“Altruism in Sports and Work”
“Aiding the Enemy?”
“What’s Fair?”
***Latvia’s new Prime Minister, Andris Kulbergs, is an avid motorsports enthuasiast and recently won a rally race. When asked whether motorsport is comparable to politics, Kulbergs answered – fluently and spontaneously – “Yes, a lot of things are similar”. In both fields, successful teamwork, trust, mutual understanding and the ability to compromise are essential, he believes. “Whether to save the brakes or tyres or push to the limits – all this you have to calculate and take into account in the end.”
***************
My book, Fables for Leaders, about how ancient stories apply to today’s workplace, can be purchased here. The link will take you to BookBaby, the well established and reputable company that prints and fills orders for Fables for Leaders.
My other book, Leading from the Middle, with essays on team building, followers, leaders, innovation and several case studies of exceptional leaders and organizations, can be purchased here at Amazon.
N.B. For other essays on numerous topics on leadership and literature and fables go to my Nucleus archive from 2010-early 2025.
NOTICE: This and all other essays found at the Leading from the Middle blog (since 2010) were/are written by John Lubans, a person.
Like books, journals and other information resources, I use AI for background and factual information. If I incorporate that information into my writing, I quote and cite the source.
If I use an AI-created image, I provide the source and the date.
© Copyright all text by John Lubans 2026
