A Serious Discussion
I am writing an article about my Fulbright teaching experiences – my course design, its content and the class outcomes - for Del Williams, the editor of Advances in Library Administration and Organization. (He had a Fulbright to teach in Klaipeda, Lithuania the same time I taught in Riga.)
Del and I discussed my assignment and whether it should be more theoretical rather than pragmatic. In our conversation, I expressed some frustration: “Librarians seem mired in the economic situation and, frankly, even when libraries were relatively flush we did not really want to hear that much about management topics. Perhaps I am wrong?”
Del expressed an opposite view: “While most librarians think it might be useful to have more management training, they still tend to be more into the pop management literature than serious discussions of the topic, so selling the topic becomes more difficult.
Perhaps, like Del says, if we can avoid the pop stuff (you know, FISH, Strategic Planning, Core Competency, Sigma Six, and Knock Your Socks Off Customer Service, etc.,) we can reflect on what it is most on our minds as managers and leaders. We can ask and discuss in depth the questions most on our minds.
As a start, I’ve developed a list of questions for that serious, frank & candid discussion (I like this painting, titled A Serious Discussion!*). What would you add, take away from my list?
1. What’s working well in our organization? What is not? What will we do about it?
2. Is the top down, boss to worker, the best model of organization for us? If not, what should replace it?
3. What contemporary leader do you admire the most? Do you emulate that leader in how you do your job?
4. Are we in a post-departmental era? Do we use the departmental arrangement less than other ways of accomplishing the work of the organization?
5. What is the most important organizational trend you are observing?
6. Is your organization reactive or proactive? If the former, do you want to shift more to the proactive? Doing so, what would be in the way and what would you do about it?
7. All of our organizations have an accumulation of problem staff, people who seem to hold the organization back. What can be done?
8. Why do some of our best staff reject management jobs beyond the team leader or departmental level? What needs to change organizationally for our best and brightest to aspire to leadership positions?
9. What training opportunities exist for staff? Are existing programs rigorous enough? What is rigor? What should a training program teach and what should be the outcomes for participants?
10. Is there evidence, factual or otherwise, to support the investment our organizations make in performance appraisal? Does PA make a provable difference? Are there better ways to let people know how they are doing or not doing?
11. How do we refresh and augment our skills as leaders?
12. What is our productivity goal?
13. What are our REAL organizational values toward each other and to our clientele?
14. If fear or anger prevents us from our open and candid discussion of any of these questions, what does that say? Does it matter?
* A Serious Discussion is by S. C. Faber, 2010. See at http://scfaber.com/gallery4.html or here.
Del and I discussed my assignment and whether it should be more theoretical rather than pragmatic. In our conversation, I expressed some frustration: “Librarians seem mired in the economic situation and, frankly, even when libraries were relatively flush we did not really want to hear that much about management topics. Perhaps I am wrong?”
Del expressed an opposite view: “While most librarians think it might be useful to have more management training, they still tend to be more into the pop management literature than serious discussions of the topic, so selling the topic becomes more difficult.
Perhaps, like Del says, if we can avoid the pop stuff (you know, FISH, Strategic Planning, Core Competency, Sigma Six, and Knock Your Socks Off Customer Service, etc.,) we can reflect on what it is most on our minds as managers and leaders. We can ask and discuss in depth the questions most on our minds.
As a start, I’ve developed a list of questions for that serious, frank & candid discussion (I like this painting, titled A Serious Discussion!*). What would you add, take away from my list?
1. What’s working well in our organization? What is not? What will we do about it?
2. Is the top down, boss to worker, the best model of organization for us? If not, what should replace it?
3. What contemporary leader do you admire the most? Do you emulate that leader in how you do your job?
4. Are we in a post-departmental era? Do we use the departmental arrangement less than other ways of accomplishing the work of the organization?
5. What is the most important organizational trend you are observing?
6. Is your organization reactive or proactive? If the former, do you want to shift more to the proactive? Doing so, what would be in the way and what would you do about it?
7. All of our organizations have an accumulation of problem staff, people who seem to hold the organization back. What can be done?
8. Why do some of our best staff reject management jobs beyond the team leader or departmental level? What needs to change organizationally for our best and brightest to aspire to leadership positions?
9. What training opportunities exist for staff? Are existing programs rigorous enough? What is rigor? What should a training program teach and what should be the outcomes for participants?
10. Is there evidence, factual or otherwise, to support the investment our organizations make in performance appraisal? Does PA make a provable difference? Are there better ways to let people know how they are doing or not doing?
11. How do we refresh and augment our skills as leaders?
12. What is our productivity goal?
13. What are our REAL organizational values toward each other and to our clientele?
14. If fear or anger prevents us from our open and candid discussion of any of these questions, what does that say? Does it matter?
* A Serious Discussion is by S. C. Faber, 2010. See at http://scfaber.com/gallery4.html or here.